top of page

Treat yourself

Menu

If you don't see what you want,

please inquire. I love special orders!

Cakes

  • cupcakes starting at $36 / dozen 

  • 8" cakes starting at $30

  • 9" cakes starting at $35

Cookies

  • starting at $20 / dozen

Pies 

  • 5" deep dish starting at $11

    • contains 1/2 a pound of fresh fruit​

  • 9" deep dish starting at $38

    • contains 2 pounds of fresh fruit​

Pastries

  • macarons starting at $36 / dozen

  • kolaches starting at $4/ piece, minimum order of 6

  • kouign amann starting at $5 / piece, minimum order of 6

  • palmiers starting at $5 / piece, minimum order of 6

Breads

  • bagels, starting at $3 / piece, minimum order of 6

    • housemade everything bagel​ seasoning

  • milk bread

  • whole wheat bread

How it Works

Step 01

Check out our menu

Oh Me, Oh Pie offers more than pies. As a pastry school graduate, I am proud to offer a wide variety of items from laminated pastries, cakes, bagels, to cookies.

Step 02

Send a message to inquire about date

All baked goods are made to order. Please order here to ensure I can prepare your order on time. To guarantee your order, you must at least pay a non-refundable 50% deposit; if this is not done at least 2 business days in advance of the date your order is needed, I cannot guarantee your order. ORDERS WILL NOT BE MADE, UNLESS PAID IN ADVANCE. Thank you for understanding. :) 

Step 03

Order is prepared

All baked goods are made in small batches to ensure quality. Items are used with only the highest quality ingredients, using free range chicken eggs and organic ingredients, when possible.

Step 04

Enjoy your

goodies 

Once your order is prepared, you can either pick them up or have them delivered to your desired location. 

banana_muffins

FAQ's

  • Where do I pickup my baked goods?
    At this time, we offer a pick up location in Caldwell and Nampa. If you would like your baked goods to be delivered, please let us know. A convenience fee will be added to your order.
  • Do you have a physical location?
    Unfortunately, there is no retail location at this time. We are a cottage-licensed home bakery operating in Caldwell. We are happy to cater your next order, though.
  • How far in advance do you need to know for custom orders?
    If we have availability, we are able to fulfill most orders within 2 days notice. However, to ensure you can get your entire order, message us a week in advance.
bottom of page